Round 102 Report - 6 dApps and voter rewards

This week, I decided to focus on a few dApps that have shown great numbers in the areas I value. I used the performance tags below to find the top candidates by hard metrics, and from there, I picked the ones I value on the softer metrics (community involvement, updates, roadmap, etc.).

The candidates were selected with this weight:

• Ecosystem Growth (New Users) (Weight: 10%)
• Account Retention (Stickiness) (Weight: 15%)
• Reward Utilization (Distribution) (Weight: 20%)
• Signaling (Weight: 30%)
• Ecosystem Synergy (Cross-Pollination) (Weight: 25%)

Signaling and ecosystem synergy were weighted the highest because they are the two metrics I believe show dApp engagement to protect the app and DAO from bad actors.

While ecosystem growth is important, it is harder to measure. One dApp that is exploited will have a large amount of new “users,” but unless those users are also using other dApps (especially in the days of B3MO Quests highly incentivizing trying new dApps), it is more likely that the users are just fake accounts.

If a dApp has both new accounts as well as a high synergy percentage, it indicates a higher amount of legitimate users.

After my motivations for the round, I’ve gathered some stats on the voter rewards from early rounds of freshness.

Let’s jump in!

---

Methodology & Scope

This report is automatically generated using indexed data from WalletWatcher. However, the voted-for-apps is manually selected by me using a mix of analysis and personal insights.

To ensure a fair and stable analysis, all growth and security metrics are calculated as a 4-round rolling total (approx. 8 weeks). Growth indicators (▲/▼) represent the change between the current window and the previous overlapping window (a 1-round shift, e.g., Rounds 94-97 vs. 93-96). This methodology filters out biweekly volatility to highlight sustained ecosystem trends.

Performance Tags & KPI Definitions

GROWTH

Ecosystem Growth: Apps bringing ≥20 new accounts into the DAO over the last 4 rounds.

DISCO

App Discovery: Existing DAO users using this app for the first time (Target: ≥30).

STICKY

Account Retention: Apps with a loyal core audience (Target: ≥70% round-over-round return rate).

HUB

Ecosystem Synergy: Percentage of new users who explored other DAO apps (Target: ≥40%).

DISTRO

Reward Utilization: Total B3TR distributed vs. total allocation received (Target: ≥70%).

SIGNAL

Bot Signaling: Active fraud prevention via community signaling (Target: ≥16 writes/resets).

Reheat’s Allocation & Notes

Navigator Allocation: Round 102

ST3PR

GROWTHDISCOSTICKYHUBSIGNAL

Reheat's Rationale:

"Since launching their native apps a few weeks back, we have seen consistent updates ( https://x.com/ST3PR_VET/status/2064277753868783665 ), a very high reward average per user, and the continued community presence with giveaways (jackpot wheel, minigames on their discord server), and they also topped the chart on the metrics above.

They’ve also been quick to implement the new function to distribute rewards based on the actual round it was performed in, making ‘pre-loading’ of actions for B3MO Quests impossible. Great stuff."

Recommendations:

"None this round."

4-Round Performance KPIs

	Ecosystem Growth	201▲4
	App Discovery	358▼3
	Account Retention	85%▲1%
	Ecosystem Synergy	45%▼12%
	Reward Utilization	51%▼2%
	Bot Signaling	60(--)

---

Cleanify

GROWTHDISCOSTICKYSIGNAL

Reheat's Rationale:

"Cleanify has been a strong trendsetter in a lot of things. I really like their fully-VBD native ‘skin in the game’ system, their ease-of-use and the new leaderboard added a few months back.

The app is simple to use and with the addition of refillable bottles and reusable bags added as an option recently, Cleanify is quickly becoming the ‘everything’ dApp.

Just like ST3PR, Cleanify was also quick to add the new distribute function for quests."

Recommendations:

"I’ve discussed this briefly before with Cleanify, but the leaderboard is too deterministic currently. Would love to see some tweaks there. If your skin in the game level is too low or you don’t time submissions perfectly, there’s no way to catch up based on performance.

In addition, with so many available actions now (that all share one cooldown), users could just do the easiest one every time, with no reason to do any of the other actions. It would be good to see reasons to try other modes (which they’ve teased a solution on with a wheel spin feature)"

4-Round Performance KPIs

	Ecosystem Growth	46▲13
	App Discovery	134▲16
	Account Retention	82%(--)
	Ecosystem Synergy	23%▼13%
	Reward Utilization	48%▼3%
	Bot Signaling	550(--)

---

Cleanmate

GROWTHDISCODISTROSIGNAL

Reheat's Rationale:

"Cleanmate has quickly risen to become a great new dApp. They’re active on their Telegram, have great support, the app itself looks good and works well. Fun to see quests from them as well. And they're great signaling users."

Recommendations:

"Some separation from its Cleanify inspiration would be great to see. Currently, it functions a little bit too similarly to Cleanify (which has a first-mover advantage). Maybe it would be possible to have just one submission type instead of 5+, and it figures out what sustainable action you’re doing out of the approved ones automatically?"

4-Round Performance KPIs

	Ecosystem Growth	314▼64
	App Discovery	664▼183
	Account Retention	62%▲3%
	Ecosystem Synergy	28%▲5%
	Reward Utilization	83%▼128%
	Bot Signaling	29(--)

---

ScoopUp

DISCOSTICKY

Reheat's Rationale:

"While the overall metrics for ScoopUp are slightly weaker than other dApps on the list this round, their trends are good, and updates on the new app are frequent. Both the founder (Mr Whittleman) and ScoopUp’s dev has been active on the VeBetterDAO community hub discord server, answering questions and listening to feedback.

The V2 of the app is looking great, now we just need the momentum to continue, so I want to support their efforts."

Recommendations:

"ScoopUp is niche by design, which is both its blessing and its curse. It’s exclusively targeted on dog owners, but this limits its growth and discovery potential. Alternatives for non-dog owners would be welcome."

4-Round Performance KPIs

	Ecosystem Growth	5▲1
	App Discovery	77▲33
	Account Retention	76%▼4%
	Ecosystem Synergy	13%(--)
	Reward Utilization	41%▲1%
	Bot Signaling	6(--)

---

Avoco

DISCOSTICKYHUBSIGNAL

Reheat's Rationale:

"A new, simplified UI from Avoco recently and their trends are still strong. Fun to see reward codes make a come-back. Also strong signalers."

Recommendations:

"Simplicity is great, but it can also feel stagnant. Over time, I’d expect more features added. Avoco could become the best nutrition/food dApp on the DAO if they expand. Other dApps in the same niche exist, but none have really flourished. The foundation is solid but the dApp needs to evolve with time."

4-Round Performance KPIs

	Ecosystem Growth	9▲2
	App Discovery	199▼6
	Account Retention	89%▼1%
	Ecosystem Synergy	42%▲25%
	Reward Utilization	59%▼18%
	Bot Signaling	35(--)

---

Green Ambassador Challenge

GROWTHDISCODISTROSIGNAL

Reheat's Rationale:

"Green Ambassador Challenge continues to deliver new challenges while participating in discussions on Discord and Telegram, contributing with their experience.

In addition, their reward utilization is very strong, despite the low B3TR value currently. This means they’re self-funding operations instead of withdrawing more to sustain themselves which is great to see."

Recommendations:

"Nothing new this round."

4-Round Performance KPIs

	Ecosystem Growth	457▼65
	App Discovery	470▼76
	Account Retention	62%▲1%
	Ecosystem Synergy	0%(--)
	Reward Utilization	87%▼20%
	Bot Signaling	196(--)

---

Closing thoughts

Last rounds we’ve looked at freshness data. Now we’ve started to see some data on the actual impact on voter rewards as well, so this week we are analysing that.

This sample is taken from round 100 votes (rewards claimed in round 101). As round 102 is not yet complete we do not yet have complete numbers from there.

‘Efficiency’ is the most interesting number here. It shows the B3TR Earnt per 100 VOT3 across the different freshness multipliers.

Takeaways

• Active voters take almost everything: The donut chart shows that the 3x Freshness group captured 89.1% of all voter rewards, even though they only made up about a quarter of the total voters (but the .

• The multiplier works exactly as designed: Voters who updated their apps this round earned rewards at a rate 3x higher ($0.5178$) than those who haven’t updated in 3+ rounds ($0.1709$).

• Most wallets are still unaware of freshness: Roughly 70% of all voters (over 10,500 votes) sat in the lowest 1x tier, meaning the vast majority of wallets are voting with stale preferences and missing out on big rewards.

---

Reheat’s Ecosystem Analysis

A data-driven deep dive into the entire VeBetterDAO ecosystem. All growth and security metrics are calculated as a 4-round rolling total to identify long-term trends and sustainable participation.

Ecosystem Funding Dominance

This leaderboard shows the total B3TR funding captured by applications in the ecosystem (Voting Allocations + Dynamic Base Allocation), and where my votes landed on this leaderboard.

#	Application	Total Funding (Inc. DBA %)	Voted
1	Mugshot	261 837 (2 137 • 1%)
2	Greencart	261 837 (2 137 • 1%)
3	ST3PR	196 479 (2 137 • 1%)	✓
4	veDelegate	170 798 (2 137 • 1%)
5	HangnDry	93 032 (2 137 • 2%)
6	Cleanify	83 798 (2 137 • 3%)	✓
7	Evearn	44 987 (2 137 • 5%)
8	EcoMeal	33 589 (2 137 • 6%)
9	Avoco	30 559 (2 137 • 7%)	✓
10	SolarWise	26 664 (2 137 • 8%)
11	Bubbles	25 077 (2 137 • 9%)
12	Cleanmate	15 555 (2 137 • 14%)	✓
13	BetterMode	14 545 (2 137 • 15%)
14	Bikademy	14 112 (2 137 • 15%)
15	BetterBag	12 669 (2 137 • 17%)
16	ScoopUp	10 938 (2 137 • 20%)	✓
17	B3DTIME	10 505 (2 137 • 20%)
18	A ZeLoop Spotter	10 361 (2 137 • 21%)
19	VeRecycle	10 216 (2 137 • 21%)
20	VeLottery	9 783 (2 137 • 22%)
21	JusTote	9 062 (2 137 • 24%)
22	BetterSwap	8 196 (2 137 • 26%)
23	ecobag	7 042 (2 137 • 30%)
24	Green Ambassador Challenge	6 609 (2 137 • 32%)	✓
25	Eat Up	6 032 (2 137 • 35%)
26	GronCard	5 311 (2 137 • 40%)
27	World of V - Green NFT Marketplace	5 167 (2 137 • 41%)
28	NFBC	4 445 (2 137 • 48%)
29	Arbor	3 868 (2 137 • 55%)
30	Turtle Labs	3 579 (2 137 • 60%)
31	Plant To Earn	2 597 (1 731 • 67%)
32	B3TR Smile	2 597 (1 731 • 67%)
33	Sproutly	2 597 (1 731 • 67%)
34	Wattly	2 164 (1 443 • 67%)
35	VeTrade	2 164 (1 443 • 67%)
36	Dappies	2 164 (1 443 • 67%)
37	NanoAct	1 731 (1 154 • 67%)
38	BigBottle	1 299 (866 • 67%)
39	Pause Your Carbon	1 299 (866 • 67%)
40	Re-Use	1 299 (866 • 67%)
41	SnapBox	433 (289 • 67%)
42	ReCircle	433 (289 • 67%)

Network Expansion (Last 4 Rounds)

Measures apps bringing new accounts into VeBetterDAO. Counts accounts whose first-ever action was on this app. Higher averages indicate sustainable ecosystem expansion.

Note: BigBottle was heavily farmed with an automated exploit, but the issue has since been resolved.

#ApplicationNew Accounts

1BigBottle35010

2BYB - Build Your Body550

3Green Ambassador Challenge457

4Mugshot414

5Cleanmate314

View Full Leaderboard

Full Ecosystem Leaderboard

#	Application	New Accounts
1	BigBottle	35010
2	BYB - Build Your Body	550
3	Green Ambassador Challenge	457
4	Mugshot	414
5	Cleanmate	314
6	veDelegate	272
7	Greencart	207
8	ST3PR	201
9	Bubbles	119
10	Evearn	77
11	World of V - Green NFT Marketplace	68
12	Wattly	66
13	Cleanify	46
14	Bikademy	42
15	VeRecycle	24
16	Eat Up	20
17	BetterBag	18
18	EcoMeal	12
19	VeTrade	11
20	B3TR Smile	9
21	Avoco	9
22	BetterMode	7
23	A ZeLoop Spotter	6
24	ScoopUp	5
25	NanoAct	4
26	Plant To Earn	3
27	B3DTIME	2
28	JusTote	2
29	ReCircle	2
30	GoPaperoo!	1
31	HangnDry	1
32	B3ttery	1
33	Arbor	1
34	Sproutly	1
35	Juicy Finance	1
36	Pause Your Carbon	1

Ecosystem Synergy (Last 4 Rounds)

Measures ecosystem value. Percentage of new accounts an app onboarded who went on to use other apps. High scores indicate apps that foster exploration rather than isolated farming.

#ApplicationScore

1Eat Up76%

2VeRecycle72%

3BetterMode63%

4EcoMeal50%

5ST3PR45%

View Full Leaderboard

Full Ecosystem Leaderboard

#	Application	Score
1	Eat Up	76%
2	VeRecycle	72%
3	BetterMode	63%
4	EcoMeal	50%
5	ST3PR	45%
6	Avoco	42%
7	BetterBag	36%
8	World of V - Green NFT Marketplace	34%
9	Cleanmate	28%
10	B3DTIME	25%
11	HangnDry	25%
12	Cleanify	23%
13	Bubbles	21%
14	Mugshot	15%
15	ScoopUp	13%
16	BigBottle	13%
17	ReCircle	13%
18	B3TR Smile	6%
19	Greencart	4%
20	Evearn	2%
21	SolarWise	0%
22	BetterSwap	0%
23	Bikademy	0%
24	NanoAct	0%
25	JusTote	0%
26	A ZeLoop Spotter	0%
27	VeTrade	0%
28	ecobag	0%
29	NFBC	0%
30	VeLottery	0%
31	Green Ambassador Challenge	0%
32	Plant To Earn	0%
33	Turtle Labs	0%
34	SnapBox	0%
35	veDelegate	0%
36	Arbor	0%
37	Sproutly	0%
38	GronCard	0%
39	Dappies	0%
40	Pause Your Carbon	0%
41	Re-Use	0%
42	Wattly	0%

Account Retention (Last 4 Rounds)

Measures sticky engagement. Percentage of accounts from the previous round who returned to use the app again. Consistent high retention is a key indicator of product-market fit.

#ApplicationRetention

1veDelegate98%

2BetterMode97%

3BetterBag96%

4VeRecycle96%

5BetterSwap95%

View Full Leaderboard

Full Ecosystem Leaderboard

#	Application	Retention
1	veDelegate	98%
2	BetterMode	97%
3	BetterBag	96%
4	VeRecycle	96%
5	BetterSwap	95%
6	Arbor	95%
7	GronCard	94%
8	B3DTIME	93%
9	Dappies	93%
10	Bubbles	90%
11	EcoMeal	90%
12	VeLottery	89%
13	Avoco	89%
14	SolarWise	88%
15	Eat Up	88%
16	HangnDry	88%
17	Sproutly	88%
18	A ZeLoop Spotter	86%
19	ecobag	85%
20	ST3PR	85%
21	Cleanify	82%
22	JusTote	80%
23	Greencart	80%
24	Evearn	79%
25	ScoopUp	76%
26	B3TR Smile	75%
27	Bikademy	74%
28	NanoAct	74%
29	Mugshot	71%
30	VeTrade	68%
31	Plant To Earn	65%
32	Wattly	65%
33	Green Ambassador Challenge	62%
34	Cleanmate	62%
35	Turtle Labs	49%
36	SnapBox	38%
37	Pause Your Carbon	32%
38	NFBC	27%
39	ReCircle	18%
40	World of V - Green NFT Marketplace	11%
41	BigBottle	9%
42	Re-Use	0%

Defensive Gap Analysis (Last 4 Rounds)

Measures dApp protections. Rewards distributed to accounts AFTER they were officially flagged as bots. This highlights where an app ignores ecosystem signals, continuing to reward bad actors already identified by others.

Methodology Note: To ensure fairness, we only count rewards distributed AFTER the account was officially signaled. If an app rewards a flagged account, it is considered a leak. Learn more about Bot Signaling

Top 5: Total B3TR Leaked

#ApplicationLeaked

1Greencart17 590 B3TR

2Mugshot8 746 B3TR

3Bubbles1 609 B3TR

4ST3PR1 561 B3TR

5Cleanify1 272 B3TR

Top 5: % of Allocation Leaked

#ApplicationLeak %

1Arbor3.1%

2Dappies1.9%

3Greencart1.7%

4NanoAct1.6%

5Bubbles1.5%

Full Leaderboard: By Total Amount

Ranked by absolute B3TR amount leaked

#	Application	B3TR Leaked
1	Greencart	17 590 B3TR
2	Mugshot	8 746 B3TR
3	Bubbles	1 609 B3TR
4	ST3PR	1 561 B3TR
5	Cleanify	1 272 B3TR
6	HangnDry	1 109 B3TR
7	Arbor	570 B3TR
8	Avoco	552 B3TR
9	Evearn	533 B3TR
10	EcoMeal	516 B3TR
11	Dappies	467 B3TR
12	SolarWise	427 B3TR
13	JusTote	362 B3TR
14	Eat Up	194 B3TR
15	Sproutly	173 B3TR
16	NanoAct	161 B3TR
17	ecobag	105 B3TR
18	BetterMode	90 B3TR
19	B3DTIME	73 B3TR
20	A ZeLoop Spotter	64 B3TR
21	Wattly	57 B3TR
22	BYB - Build Your Body	53 B3TR
23	BigBottle	36 B3TR
24	Cleanmate	34 B3TR
25	World of V - Green NFT Marketplace	32 B3TR
26	BetterBag	30 B3TR
27	B3TR Smile	24 B3TR
28	Green Ambassador Challenge	22 B3TR
29	ReCircle	11 B3TR
30	VeRecycle	5 B3TR
31	B3ttery	5 B3TR
32	Plant To Earn	3 B3TR
33	Turtle Labs	2 B3TR
34	SnapBox	1 B3TR
35	VeTrade	0 B3TR
36	veDelegate	0 B3TR

Full Leaderboard: By % of Allocation

Ranked by percentage of total allocation leaked

#	Application	Leak %
1	Arbor	3.1%
2	Dappies	1.9%
3	Greencart	1.7%
4	NanoAct	1.6%
5	Bubbles	1.5%
6	Sproutly	1.5%
7	JusTote	1.0%
8	Mugshot	0.8%
9	Eat Up	0.7%
10	Wattly	0.6%
11	Avoco	0.6%
12	BigBottle	0.5%
13	BYB - Build Your Body	0.5%
14	ReCircle	0.5%
15	Cleanify	0.5%
16	EcoMeal	0.4%
17	SolarWise	0.4%
18	ecobag	0.3%
19	HangnDry	0.3%
20	Evearn	0.3%
21	A ZeLoop Spotter	0.2%
22	ST3PR	0.2%
23	B3TR Smile	0.2%
24	World of V - Green NFT Marketplace	0.2%
25	B3DTIME	0.2%
26	BetterMode	0.2%
27	Cleanmate	0.1%
28	Green Ambassador Challenge	0.1%
29	SnapBox	0.1%
30	BetterBag	0.1%
31	Plant To Earn	0.0%
32	Turtle Labs	0.0%
33	VeRecycle	0.0%
34	VeTrade	0.0%
35	veDelegate	0.0%
36	B3ttery	0.0%

Bot Signaling & Fraud Prevention (28-Day Activity)

Measures active defense. Apps using their SIGNALER_ROLE to flag suspicious addresses (bots/scammers) to the VeBetter ecosystem. These are the apps doing the “hard work” to protect the ecosystem for everyone else. “Writes” are new signals created, while “Resets” are removals of prior signals (often used to revert accidental/collateral signals).

For more information on how to integrate these checks, see the VeBetterDAO Bot Signaling Docs.

Note: Mugshot has signaled a vast amount of farmer wallets that were ‘kept alive’ with their monthly leaderboard rewards counting as valid proofs. This was a one-off signal on June 7th and not a continued signaling pattern since. Kudos to Morb for pushing them to signal these wallets. Thanks Mugshot for signaling.

#ApplicationSignals

1Mugshot2667 writes, 0 resets

2Cleanify549 writes, 1 resets

3Green Ambassador Challenge179 writes, 17 resets

4ST3PR56 writes, 4 resets

5ReCircle44 writes, 3 resets

View Full Leaderboard

Full Ecosystem Leaderboard

#	Application	Writes	Resets	Total
1	Mugshot	2667	0	2667
2	Cleanify	549	1	550
3	Green Ambassador Challenge	179	17	196
4	ST3PR	56	4	60
5	ReCircle	44	3	47
6	Avoco	35	0	35
7	Cleanmate	28	1	29
8	HangnDry	15	0	15
9	ScoopUp	6	0	6
10	A ZeLoop Spotter	6	0	6

Data Dump

The raw (non-aggregated) data for this report, including transaction IDs, can be found in the link below.

Pending, will be added tomorrow 11th of June

---

Navigator Profile

Reheat

Data-driven analysis and strategic insights for the VeBetterDAO allocation and proposal voting. Delegate to support consistent, high-fidelity reporting and knowledgeable vote selection.

Navigator Profile X / Twitter

For questions or feedback regarding this report, please reach out via X.